问:「伊川谓『不当于喜怒哀乐未发之前求中』,延平却教学者『看未发之前气象』,何如?」
先生曰:「皆是也。伊川恐人于未发前讨个中,把中做一物看,如吾向所谓认气定时做中,故令只于涵养省察上用功。延平恐人未便有下手处,故令人时时刻刻求未发前气象,使人正目而视惟此,倾耳而听惟此,即是『戒慎不睹,恐惧不闻』的工夫。皆古人不得已诱人之言也。」
有人问:「程颐说『不应当在喜怒哀乐未发之前求中』,李延平却教学生『观察未发之前的气象』,怎么样?」
先生说:「都对。程颐是怕人在未发之前讨一个『中』,把中当作一件东西看,如同我从前所说把气定认作中,所以让人只在涵养省察上用功。延平是怕人没有下手处,所以让人时时刻刻体察未发前的气象,使人睁眼看的只是这个,侧耳听的只是这个,这就是『戒慎不睹、恐惧不闻』的功夫。都是古人不得已引导人的话。」
Someone asked: 'Cheng Yi said one must not seek equilibrium before the feelings are aroused; yet Yanping taught students to observe the weather of the mind before arousal. How so?'
The Master said: 'Both are right. Cheng Yi feared people would hunt for a 'mean' before arousal, treating it as a thing — like my earlier point about mistaking settled breath for equilibrium — so he directed work to nourishing and examining. Yanping feared people would have nowhere to begin, so he had them attend every moment to that pre-arousal weather, eye and ear given to this alone — which is just the work of vigilance over the unseen and unheard. Both were words the ancients used of necessity to guide people.'